Check that every quotation describes the same job
Start by attaching the same dated brief, drawings, specification and addenda to each request. Record the quotation reference, date, supplier or contractor identity, currency, validity period and the documents received. If one bidder has priced a different revision, treat the offers as incomparable until the difference is reconciled. List the work packages and ask each respondent to mark included, excluded, provisional or not priced. A low total can reflect missing scope rather than better value. Never infer that an item is included merely because it seems normal for the trade.
Compare line items, assumptions and exclusions
Use a table with scope description, quantity basis, unit, rate or allowance, total, source document, assumptions and clarification status. Compare mobilisation, temporary works, access, protection, waste handling, testing, commissioning, reinstatement, transport, storage, taxes and handover records when they apply. Record whether materials are named by performance or by brand, and whether substitutions require approval. Capture payment stages, retention, advance payments, price-adjustment wording, programme assumptions and who supplies utilities or security. Do not rewrite a contractor’s offer in a way that changes its meaning; keep the original attached to the comparison.
Test the method of evaluation
Separate technical responsiveness, qualifications, capacity, references, financial comparison and programme from the headline price. Verify claims with the issuing body or referee, using the current documents and official contact details. A certificate, company profile, social page or photograph alone does not prove that a provider is suitable for your scope. If the work is a public procurement, follow the procuring entity’s tender documents and current Procurement Regulatory Authority of Zimbabwe (PRAZ) guidance; a private comparison spreadsheet is not a replacement for the formal process. Write down the evaluation method before scoring, and keep the evidence for each score.
Request clarifications fairly
Send the same material clarification to every respondent where procurement rules or the agreed process require equal treatment. Ask one specific question at a time: identify the item, quote the conflicting documents, request confirmation and set a reasonable response date. Log replies and issue any revised scope to all participants. Do not negotiate a change through an undocumented call and then compare it with unchanged written bids. When the choice is made, keep the approval record, final price basis, exclusions, programme and the contract version together. Then use a change log so post-award instructions do not silently undo the agreed comparison.